Beyond Pinterest: How To Create Engagement Photos That Actually Feel Like You

You’ve been scrolling through Pinterest for hours. You’ve pinned a thousand perfect moments—gorgeous couples laughing in golden hour light, romantic poses under string lights, candid shots that somehow look effortlessly beautiful. And here’s the thing: those photos are stunning. But there’s something missing.

They don’t look like you.

Here’s what we’ve learned after photographing hundreds of couples in South Carolina and beyond: the most Pinterest-worthy photos aren’t the ones taken for Pinterest. They’re the ones that capture something so authentically you—so uniquely your relationship—that people can’t help but stop scrolling and say, “Wow.”

The Difference Between Looking Good and Feeling Like Yourself

Let’s be honest. There’s a reason certain engagement photos get thousands of likes. They’re well-composed. The lighting is gorgeous. The poses are flattering. The couple looks happy.

But here’s what separates the photos that make people pause: they feel real.

When we talk about candid photography, documentary-style moments, and editorial poses that still feel natural, what we’re really talking about is this: creating space for you to be yourself in front of the camera. Not performing for Instagram. Not trying to recreate someone else’s engagement shoot. Just being the couple you actually are, on a day that’s designed entirely around what makes your relationship unique.

The Pinterest photos you love probably resonate with you because they capture a feeling—romantic, cozy, spicy, rebellious, adventurous, intimate. Your job during your engagement session isn’t to recreate those exact shots. It’s to let us understand the feeling you want to evoke, and then we’ll build an entire session around bringing that feeling to life through your authentic selves.

How We Actually Get There: Our Engagement Session Process

We’re not going to pretend there’s some magical photography trick that makes couples look naturally beautiful and connected without any intention behind it. There is intention. There’s direction. There’s strategy. But here’s where we do things differently:

We start with getting to know you.

When you book with us, you’re not just scheduling a session. You’re filling out a detailed questionnaire that goes way beyond “what’s your favorite color?” We’re asking the real questions:

• What do you actually enjoy doing together on a regular Saturday?
• Are there places you frequent that hold meaning for you—the coffee shop where you always grab your morning drink, the hiking trail you love, the dive bar where you feel most like yourselves?
• How do you interact when no one’s watching? Are you the type of couple that’s playful and silly, or do you prefer a more structured, intimate dynamic?
• If you could describe the vibe of your photos, what would it be? Romantic nostalgia? Cinematic and moody? Light and joyful? Delightfully weird?

This questionnaire is our foundation. It tells us who you actually are, so we’re not making assumptions or pushing you into poses that feel uncomfortable or inauthentic.

We collaborate on the game plan.

Yes, your Pinterest board matters. Bring it. Show us what speaks to you. But here’s what we’re actually looking for: the feeling behind those images. Is it the lighting that gets you? The poses? The locations? The way the couple interacts?

Understanding the vibe you’re drawn to helps us create a roadmap for your session. It’s not about recreating specific shots—it’s about capturing images that feel the way you want them to feel, but through the lens of your actual relationship.

We build a session around your real life.

Some of our favorite engagement sessions have looked nothing like traditional engagement photos. We’ve done board game dates where we captured genuine laughter and competitiveness. We’ve gone to arcades, ordered pizza, taken photos at your favorite restaurant. We’ve incorporated activities you actually enjoy, which means you’re not just standing around trying to look cute—you’re doing something, which makes you relax and be yourselves.

But we also honor the desire to dress up and be fancy if that’s what you want. Maybe you never get the chance to wear that incredible outfit, or maybe there’s a location that feels like a daydream you’ve always wanted to experience. We’re 100% here for that too.

We help you find the sweet spot between direction and authenticity.

Here’s something important: candid doesn’t mean unguided. Documentary doesn’t mean we’re just hoping something good happens. Editorial doesn’t have to feel stiff or posed.

Our approach is customized to how you move through the world. If you’re introverted and prefer structure, we’ll give you clear direction and poses that feel natural to your personality. If you’re the type of couple that’s always laughing and being goofy, we’ll incorporate movement, games, and prompts that let that shine. If you want a mix, we’ll build in both intimate moments and playful ones.

The questionnaire tells us which approach resonates with you, and your engagement session is partially a chance for us to feel out what works best before your wedding day. We’ll gently encourage you to try things you might not expect to like—a prompt that seems weird at first, a location you hadn’t considered, a type of interaction you’re hesitant about. You might be surprised at how great you look when you’re having fun in ways that feel genuinely you.

What Makes a Photo Actually Pinterest-Worthy

Let’s talk about those stunning Pinterest photos you’ve been pinning. What makes them stop the scroll?

They’re different. They have personality. They feel like a specific love story, not a generic engagement shoot. The couple looks relaxed and connected. The poses might be directional, but they don’t look uncomfortable. The setting feels intentional. The light is beautiful, but it’s not trying too hard.

In other words: they look authentically, unapologetically like that specific couple.

When you show up to your engagement session as yourself—with your real style, your actual hobbies, your genuine personality—that’s when the magic happens. That’s when you get the kind of photos that stand out, that feel cinematic and romantic and true, that make people pause mid-scroll.

And here’s the bonus: those authentically-you photos? They’re infinitely more Pinterest-worthy than recreating someone else’s vision.

A Different Kind of Collaboration

Your engagement session isn’t just a photo shoot. It’s a collaboration. We bring years of experience, technical skill, creative vision, and an understanding of what photographs well in different situations. You bring your authenticity, your story, your personality, and your vision for how you want this day to feel.

We’re here to guide you, support your decisions, and capture moments that matter. We listen when you tell us what makes your relationship tick, and we use that information to create something that feels entirely yours.

By the time you walk into your wedding day, we won’t be strangers learning how you interact for the first time. We’ll know your dynamic. We’ll know how to direct you. We’ll know where to position ourselves to catch those unguarded moments that make your heart skip. And you’ll know that your photographer genuinely gets your vision and is invested in bringing it to life.

Ready to Plan an Engagement Session That Feels Like You?

Your engagement photos should be a reflection of your relationship—not a checklist of poses from someone else’s Pinterest board. Whether you’re planning an intimate elopement or a big celebration, whether you’re adventurous or cozy, whether you’re quirky or romantic (or both), your engagement session should feel like the beginning of documenting your love story exactly as it is.

Bring your Pinterest board. Tell us your story. Show up as yourselves.

And let’s create photos that are so authentically, gorgeously you that people can’t help but stop scrolling.

---

Ready to book your engagement session? Head to our contact page to get in touch. We’d love to collaborate with you on creating images that feel like the highlight reel of your love story.